Commander O'Neil

An old commander in the heart of the rotting swamp of Aeonia: he strikes rarely but heavily, raising his standard to call spectral soldiers and turn the duel into a battle with a squad.
- HP
- 9,211
- HP in NG+
- 13,457
- Stance
- 90
- Runes for the win
- 12,000
- Character level
- 50-70
Encounters
- (main encounter, Show on the map)
Damage taken
| standard | ×0.9 |
|---|---|
| slash | ×0.65 |
| strike | ×0.9 |
| thrust | ×1 |
| magic | ×0.8 |
| fire | ×0.8 |
| lightning | ×0.8 |
| holy | ×0.8 |
Status thresholds
| bleed | 332 |
|---|---|
| frost | 332 |
| poison | 332 |
| rot | immune |
| sleep | 332 |
Lore
Swamp of Aeonia appeared where Malenia and Radahn fought. Malenia unleashed rot, disfiguring Caelid. O'Neil is a veteran of that war who stayed on the battlefield. The game never states which side he fought for, and his equipment allows different guesses.
Something else matters more: in the swamp's heart, where rot kills in minutes, he remains alive and sane. The explanation lies in his hands. He keeps a golden needle made to contain rot within the body. It seems this alone prevents him from turning into one of those wandering the surrounding swamp.
His soldiers have long been dead, but still answer his call. The commander's standard raises their spirits, which form ranks as they did in life. That sums up O'Neil: a man who could not leave a battle long since ended and would not release those who died in it.
Where to find
The middle of Swamp of Aeonia in Caelid. The nearest site of grace is Inner Aeonia; the commander stands just south of it.
The journey is the difficulty: rot covers the swamp, filling the gauge in just a few steps on foot. Cross it on horseback: while mounted, ground rot does not build up on you. There is no fog gate, and the clearing is open: your steed stays with you during the fight, and you can ride away from the commander to heal.
The fight is optional for the main story, but you cannot advance Millicent's story without it.
Fighting style
O'Neil is a tall warrior in heavy armour, carrying a halberd with a standard attached to its shaft. He moves slowly himself, making wide halberd sweeps and thrusts. His most dangerous move is a whirlwind: he spins his weapon in broad circles, raising a large cloud of rot around him. A shorter version covers only the space immediately nearby.
The real difficulty is his squad rather than the commander. At the very start, he signals and infantry spirits with swords and crossbows rise nearby. He then raises his standard and shouts: the phantoms grow fiercer, turning the duel into a melee where someone is always behind you.
Phases
Phase 1: Commander and infantry
The first wave of spirits is weak: each falls in one or two hits. Clear them immediately while the commander is busy with his standard, then turn to him. If you leave the infantry, they will interrupt your attacks and prevent healing.
Strike O'Neil himself from behind after a completed swing. When you see him start spinning his halberd, move as far away as possible: the rot cloud is wide, and you cannot stay inside it.
Phase 2: Second squad
In the second half of the fight, with less than half his health remaining, the commander calls reinforcements. There are fewer of these spirits, but they are larger and tougher than the first. Decide on the spot: clear the field again, or leave the phantoms to your spirits and finish the commander. Watch the rot gauge until the very end.
Weak points
Thrust damage works against O'Neil without reduction. Standard and strike are slightly reduced, while slash is weakened most, by roughly a third. Magic, fire, lightning and holy are reduced equally and moderately: your choice of element makes little difference.
Rot does not affect him, unsurprisingly for a swamp dweller. Bleed, frost, poison and sleep work, all with the same threshold. Sleep is especially valuable: a sleeping commander stops resisting for several seconds.
He loses his stance after several heavy hits in succession, opening him to a critical hit.
How to win
Melee
Spears, thrusting swords and other thrust weapons are best: thrust damage suffers no reduction, and a long shaft lets you strike from behind a shield. Swords that slash are noticeably weaker against the commander himself, but useful against the infantry.
The order is simple: spirits first, commander second. Get behind him, strike twice and withdraw as soon as he starts spinning his halberd. Mounted combat is convenient too: ride in, land one or two strikes and retreat. Bleed or frost weapons speed up the fight: both status effects work.
Magic and ranged combat
A lone mage has little room here: the infantry closes in while you cast. Summon your spirits first, then fire at the commander from behind them. Any element works; all have their damage reduced equally.
You can put O'Neil to sleep with Sleep Pot or Sword of St. Trina, if you have them. While he sleeps, you have time to land several strikes or heal peacefully.
Help in battle
Spirits are more necessary here than in most fights: squad against squad. Lone Wolf Ashes tie up the infantry, Spirit Jellyfish Ashes poisons the commander himself, and Banished Knight Oleg withstands his attacks.
If Sage Gowry has already asked you to bring the needle, a summon sign appears by the clearing: Polyanna, Adopted Daughter. Remember that your steed is unavailable with a summoned ally.
Bring Preserving Boluses: they remove accumulated rot and an infection that has already begun. Without them, one unlucky cloud can cost you the entire fight.
Tips
- Cross the swamp on horseback: you do not have to dismount before the fight.
- Clear the first spirit wave immediately: it is weak but more disruptive than the commander himself.
- A spinning halberd means a rot cloud. Retreat and wait for it to disperse.
- Do not waste rot on O'Neil: he is immune to it.
- Keep rot-curing boluses in a quick slot rather than buried in your bag.
After the fight
You receive runes, Commander's Standard and Unalloyed Gold Needle. The Heart of Aeonia site of grace appears in the arena. Take the needle to Sage Gowry in Gowry's Shack near Sellia: it begins Millicent's story, one of the longest in the game.